Securing a construction contract often requires more than a competitive bid and a strong track record. Project owners need financial assurance that contractors will meet their obligations—enter surety bonds and letters of credit. These tools serve as safety nets for project stakeholders, but they function in very different ways.
While both options offer performance guarantees, the choice between a surety bond and a letter of credit can significantly affect your working capital, risk exposure, and business flexibility. For contractors, understanding these differences is key to selecting the right financial instrument for your projects.
Explore surety bond solutions with St. Andrews Insurance to protect your projects and maintain your financial agility.
This guide will break down both options, examine their key differences, and help you determine which might be the better choice for your specific contracting needs.
What Are Surety Bonds?
A surety bond is a three-party agreement involving the contractor (principal), the project owner (obligee), and a surety company (surety). The surety company guarantees to the project owner that the contractor will fulfil their contractual obligations. If the contractor fails to complete the work or meet the terms of the contract, the surety company steps in to remedy the situation.
How Surety Bonds Work
The surety company evaluates the contractor’s financial stability, work history, and capacity to complete the project before issuing the bond. This process involves a thorough underwriting review, similar to applying for a loan. The contractor pays a premium to the surety company, typically ranging from 1% to 3% of the bond amount.
If a claim is made against the bond, the surety company investigates the situation. They may choose to help the contractor complete the project, hire a replacement contractor, or compensate the project owner for losses. However, the contractor remains ultimately responsible for any costs incurred by the surety company and must reimburse them.
Benefits of Surety Bonds for Contractors
Surety bonds offer several advantages that make them attractive to contractors:
Cash Flow Preservation: Since surety bonds don’t require contractors to tie up cash or credit lines, they preserve working capital for operations and other business needs.
Enhanced Credibility: Having a surety bond demonstrates to project owners that a third-party has evaluated and approved your company’s financial stability and capability.
Competitive Advantage: Many public projects and large private contracts require surety bonds, so having bonding capacity allows contractors to bid on more opportunities.
Risk Management Support: Surety companies often provide risk management guidance and project monitoring services to help prevent problems before they occur.
What Are Letters of Credit?
A letter of credit is a financial instrument issued by a bank on behalf of the contractor, guaranteeing payment to the project owner if specific conditions are met. Unlike surety bonds, letters of credit are essentially a bank’s promise to pay, backed by the contractor’s own financial resources.
How Letters of Credit Work
To obtain a letter of credit, contractors must apply through their bank and provide collateral equal to the full amount of the letter of credit. This collateral is typically in the form of cash, securities, or other liquid assets that the bank holds as security. The bank charges a fee for issuing the letter of credit, usually between 1% and 2% annually of the face value.
When a project owner makes a claim against a letter of credit, the bank pays out immediately upon presentation of the required documentation. The bank then seeks reimbursement from the contractor through the collateral that was posted.
Benefits of Letters of Credit for Contractors
Letters of credit provide certain advantages in specific situations:
Faster Processing: Banks can often issue letters of credit more quickly than surety companies can underwrite and issue bonds.
Less Scrutiny: Banks focus primarily on the contractor’s ability to provide adequate collateral rather than conducting extensive operational reviews.
Flexibility: Letters of credit can be structured for various purposes and may be easier to modify than surety bonds.
International Projects: For contractors working on international projects, letters of credit are often more readily accepted and understood globally.
Key Differences Between Surety Bonds and Letters of Credit
Understanding the fundamental differences between these two financial instruments is essential for making the right choice for your contracting business.
Financial Impact
The most significant difference lies in how each option affects your company’s finances. Surety bonds preserve cash flow since they don’t require collateral, while letters of credit tie up the full amount in cash or other liquid assets. This cash tie-up can significantly impact a contractor’s ability to fund operations, purchase materials, or pursue other opportunities.
Risk Transfer
Surety bonds involve genuine risk transfer, as the surety company assumes responsibility for investigating claims and has an incentive to help contractors succeed. Letters of credit, however, offer no risk transfer since the contractor’s own money backs the instrument.
Claims Process
The claims process differs substantially between the two options. Surety companies investigate claims thoroughly and may dispute invalid claims or work to resolve issues. Banks, conversely, pay out letters of credit immediately upon proper documentation, regardless of whether the claim is justified.
Ongoing Relationship
Surety companies maintain ongoing relationships with contractors, providing guidance and support throughout projects. Banks typically have minimal involvement once the letter of credit is issued, offering no project support or risk management services.
Which Option Is Better for Different Situations?
The choice between surety bonds and letters of credit depends on various factors specific to your business and project requirements.
When Surety Bonds Are Preferable
Surety bonds are typically the better choice for contractors who:
- Want to preserve cash flow and working capital
- Are bidding on public projects or large private contracts
- Seek ongoing support and risk management guidance
- Have established relationships with surety companies
- Are working on long-term projects where ongoing support is valuable
Most established contractors prefer surety bonds because they don’t tie up cash and provide additional value through the surety company’s expertise and support.
When Letters of Credit Might Be Better
Letters of credit may be the preferred option when:
- Speed is crucial and bonds would take too long to obtain
- The contractor has limited bonding capacity
- Working on international projects where letters of credit are standard
- The project owner specifically requires a letter of credit
- The contractor has excess cash that won’t be needed for operations
Smaller contractors or those with limited bonding capacity might find letters of credit more accessible, though the cash requirements can still be challenging.
Making the Right Choice for Your Business
Choosing between surety bonds and letters of credit requires careful consideration of your company’s financial position, project requirements, and long-term business goals. Most successful contractors develop bonding relationships early in their careers, as surety bonds typically offer more advantages for growing businesses.
Consider consulting with both surety professionals and your banking partners to understand what options are available for your specific situation. The right choice can significantly impact your company’s growth potential and financial stability.
Both surety bonds and letters of credit serve important roles in the construction industry, but surety bonds generally provide more value for contractors through cash flow preservation, risk management support, and competitive advantages. However, letters of credit remain valuable tools in certain situations, particularly when speed or international acceptance is important.